One of Amazon’s recent announcements was to promote it’s logistics services for businesses – in effect, becoming a competitive parcel carrier. ColdTrack’s Vice President of Supply Chain, Dan Schwartz has been following the news so we asked him what this could mean for perishable product manufacturers and their direct-to-consumer business. Dan wrote our latest post below – take it away, Dan!
The small parcel delivery market has been defined by a few key names for decades: UPS, FedEx, USPS, and DHL. While regional carriers have steadily expanded their footprints over the past several years, Amazon’s recent decision to aggressively pursue third-party parcel shipping represents another significant shift in the transportation landscape. Whether Amazon ultimately becomes a major carrier for commercial shippers remains to be seen. What isn’t up for debate is that its entry is already influencing pricing, service expectations, and competitive dynamics across the industry.
We don’t necessarily view this as a reason to rush toward or away from any one carrier. We see it as another opportunity to evaluate where a new transportation option may create value for perishable product manufacturers and our customers.
Every Carrier Has a Role
One of the advantages of operating a dynamic, multi-carrier transportation network like we do is that we aren’t dependent on a single provider. Our goal has never been to find the best carrier. It’s to identify the best carrier for each individual to-door perishable shipment. It’s that philosophy that has guided our approach as we’ve added regional carriers like Jitsu and OnTrac alongside established national providers. Amazon Shipping deserves our same objective evaluation.
Today, Amazon appears particularly well positioned for certain shipping profiles. Its growing residential delivery network, competitive pricing, seven-day operations, and strong consumer delivery experience make it an intriguing option for many ambient and shelf-stable products where transit times of several days are acceptable.
For frozen and refrigerated shipments, however, the evaluation becomes more nuanced. Speed, consistency, and delivery reliability often matter just as much as transportation cost. As Amazon’s commercial offerings continue to evolve, we’ll continue evaluating where those services may complement our existing carrier network.
The Cheapest Rate Isn’t Always the Lowest Cost
One of the biggest mistakes we see companies make is evaluating transportation based solely on the carrier invoice. Transportation isn’t just a cost center – it’s a critical part of the customer experience.
During our panel discussion at Home Delivery World, our Chief Revenue Officer Warner Siebert made an observation that resonated with many brands in attendance: a single delivery failure can erase the transportation savings from dozens of lower-cost shipments.
For temperature-controlled products, the consequences extend even further. A late delivery often means spoiled product. This doesn’t simply result in an unhappy customer – it can require replacing the product, paying for expedited reshipment, handling additional customer service inquiries, and potentially losing a customer altogether.
When those downstream costs are considered, the “cheapest” transportation option can quickly become the most expensive.
That’s why we evaluate carriers using a much broader set of criteria than rate alone, including historical on-time performance, transit consistency, geographic coverage, service availability, and shipment characteristics.
Technology Makes Carrier Choice Smarter
Perhaps the biggest advantage for ColdTrack customers is that they don’t have to bet on a single carrier. Our transportation logic that’s built-in to ColdTrack Live™ already evaluates each shipment individually, considering factors such as destination, product characteristics, transit requirements, and carrier performance to recommend the most appropriate transportation option.
As new carriers enter the market, or existing carriers introduce new services, we evaluate them alongside the rest of our network and incorporate them where they deliver measurable value. That flexibility allows our customers to benefit from innovation without continually redesigning their transportation strategy.
Looking Ahead
Amazon Shipping is an important development for our industry, and we expect its capabilities to continue expanding over time. As with every transportation provider we evaluate, our focus isn’t on headlines or introductory pricing. It’s on long-term performance and whether a carrier can consistently help our customers deliver exceptional experiences to their own customers.
We’ll continue testing, measuring, and monitoring the market as it evolves. If Amazon proves to be the best option for certain shipping profiles, we’ll incorporate it where it makes sense.
At the end of the day, our responsibility isn’t to promote carriers. It’s to recommend the right one.
Thanks Dan!
If you’re still working with one carrier but need greater flexibility, we can guide you on what to look for and show you how we might be able to help. Let’s chat.